Our Companies

First Choice Insurance offers insurance policies through the following reputable insurance providers to bring you the coverage that works best for you.

MetLife
Toll Free: 800-680-3354
Claims: 800-243-5860

Progressive
Toll Free: 800-876-5581
Claims: 800-888-7764

Mutual of Enumclaw
Toll Free: 800-456-7750
Claims: 877-425-2580

Dairyland Auto
Toll Free: 800-334-0090
Claims: 800-334-0090

Gem State Insurance Company
Phone: 208-934-5833

Safeco Insurance
Toll Free: 800-332-3226

United Heritage Insurance
Phone: 800-657-6351

Grundy Worldwide
Toll Free: 800-338-4005

Hagerty
Toll Free: 800-922-4050
Claims: 800-922-4050