What our clients say

Taylor B.
"Dewight and Lloyd are honest, genuine insurance pro's. I would highly recommend them."
Marcy M.
"First Choice is definitely our choice and Gabe Allen is by far, the BEST insurance agent we have ever worked with!!! We highly recommend him for his commitment to finding the best possible policy and making sure we're covered at the best possible price. Unparalleled customer service, too! Thanks, First Choice, for always having our backs!"
Justin H.

"Such an easy way to find great rates. They made it very fast and simple for me. Recommend everyone to go see them."

No Matter What You Need, We’ve Got You Covered

The Team You Can Trust To Get It Done Right

Started in 2009 First Choice is a locally owned, full service agency licensed in the state of Idaho and Utah. We’ve quickly become one of the most respected and fastest growing insurance agencies in Southeast Idaho. As an independent agency, First Choice has the benefit of working with multiple carriers to get you the insurance you need at the price you can afford. Let one of our knowledgeable and friendly staff give you the peace of mind you deserve, knowing your assets are well protected. Peace of mind is a choice. Make the right choice. Make it First Choice!

Our Carriers

Get a Quote

By submitting this form I acknowledge that I could be contacted by First Choice Insurance via Text Message.

Contact Info